Paulie Gee's Wicker Park

Pierre 2 months ago

This isn't your typical greasy slice joint, thankfully. It’s proper pizza that’s worth the few extra dollars. I usually swing by after work, and while it can get busy, the quality always makes up for any wait. A dependable choice for a good meal.

John McGuire 3 months ago

Title: Disappointing lunch experience and bizarre customer service I decided to stop by WP Paulie Gee’s right after they opened at 11:00 AM for an early lunch, but unfortunately, it ended with me walking out without my food or a refund. The visit started fine. The person making pizzas acknowledged me right away and said someone would be right with me. A minute later, another employee took my order for two slices and processed my payment. Because I prefer my pizza warm rather than scalding hot, I politely requested this when ordering. The employee nodded in understanding. However, a minute later, she handed me slices straight out of the oven that were far too hot to even hold. When I went back to the counter to ask for a simple exchange, the original employee wasn't there. As I was calmly explaining the situation to a second employee, a third staff member suddenly stepped in and accused me of raising my voice (which I absolutely was not) and implied I was being rude for explaining my reason for an exchange. Being wrongfully shamed and accused of being aggressive just for asking for what I actually ordered was incredibly frustrating and bewildering. Instead of arguing, I chose to

Euny S 3 months ago

Loved the vegan pizza! They use a local vegan coconut based cheese that is so delicious! Super thin crust that is so delicious! Really cool ambience too—so casual and young. The guy behind the counter was also really cool. The pizzas are a little pricey but I think totally worth it! Some of the best vegan pizza I’ve had!

AYO MILLZ 5 months ago

I visited this location Monday, May 4th, 2026 about 4:30pm and ordered a slice of their wicker baby, vodka roni and a Dr. Pepper for dine-in... everything was pleasant until I received my order and requested for parmesan which turned into this big deal... I was told that I couldn't get parmesan because they finish their pizzas with it already, then because they don't use cheap parmesan and it's too expensive and they don't sale it on the side either... a little odd for a pizza place who has seasonings like oregano and crushed peppers available but this was also an white staff with one trans employee in a white neighborhood and is only my experience as a Black man. Do with that information as you see fit. However - this is not a place that I can recommend to patronize

Kovas Palubinskas 10 months ago

Several non-meat slice options, quickly heated and came out got, which is great. Chewy for a thin crust, slightly less sauce would have kept the crust firmer and easier to eat. Overall a positive stop.